Sloppy Forgeries Review – Paint Fast, Cry Later
Art is subjective, but this is something else.
Sloppy Forgeries is the best art ‘game’ I think I’ve played. Mario Paint wasn’t a game, and those paint-by-numbers aren’t exactly a game either, but more like an interactive colouring book. Well, duh. Forgive the play on words, but Playful Systems’ competitive painting game truly is a work of art.
The developers can’t take credit for the art on show. That’s not because it’s AI slop, but because it’s generated from real classical art pieces. From American Gothic to the Mona Lisa, the game covers around 50 timeless pieces, spanning a range of Renaissance, Romanticism, and Contemporary Art, and while it caters to a range of tastes, don’t expect to be doodling things like ‘I woz ere’ or dick pics.
Your role in Sloppy Forgeries, unsurprisingly, is to recreate a masterpiece in a couple of minutes using just your mouse. There are no undo buttons, erasers or magic wand tools, just a standard three brush widths and a limited palette that matches the art you’re reconstructing.
Pixel Perfect
No doubt you’ve played something like this before, and most likely, a mobile game like Gartic Phone or perhaps you’ve also got Drawful in your family collection, as we do? Drawing on a tablet is better for the young ‘uns, as my daughter insisted she can’t use an archaic mouse, but it’s more to do with planning than pixel perfection. Contradiction coming up.

There are ten collections to work through in the ‘campaign’, but you can tackle any of the five pieces in any order. Completing all five will unlock the next collection and so on, though you can toggle all paintings on in the menu (I don’t recommend it). The clock will start, and you then need to cover the canvas in as much colour as possible.
Sloppy Forgeries’ default brushes are rubbish for detail, though that’s not as important as the key thing is to fill with as much of the colours as the original and scale accordingly. By getting the correct coverage earlier on, you can in fact unlock smaller brushes during the challenge to help fine-tune things, and while they aren’t super fine, they allow you to shape your art better.
Everyone’s a Critic
Once the time is up, your forgery is scanned using AI and given a percentage on how close you are to the original. This typically focuses on coverage and scale, so making it look pretty doesn’t always guarantee a decent ranking. Unsurprisingly, Contemporary Art is easier with its basic shapes, and anyone familiar with layers will get an S-Rank on the first go.

Then you progress through art history and get your first C. Fortunately, I didn’t get this that frequently in Sloppy Forgeries, and to be honest, it wouldn’t have put me off, as it’s highly addictive, but equally stressful. Using classical music to match the art, it’s intense, and as the time ticks down, the music gets more chaotic and uncomfortable, at least when playing alone.
Everyone’s a Critic
There is one lifeline: you can toggle a grid for a total of 30 seconds to help with scaling, but even then, I managed to get through a flat five collections as I was so determined to seek everything out, then go back and perfect it. An overall rank is given per collection, using the lowest-scoring one as the one you need to improve on first.
I love Sloppy Forgeries, but as I mentioned, it’s stressful. I appreciate that it’s the point of the game to recreate a work of art in a couple of minutes, but it would have been nice to have a non-competitive option to switch off the timer. All other scores are logged on a leaderboard, but toggling a timer on and off would make this a bonus wholesome experience when you’re done.

Putting that to one side, one of the biggest standouts is the two-player option. Not everyone wants to play online, so it’s great to have a local option. But how? Two mice! From my perspective, the mouse is absolutely fine, but my iPad kid daughter wanted a touchscreen.
Two-Player is the Main Event
While Sloppy Forgeries boasts Wacom support, to touch (pun!) on a retro handheld reference, this can be played via something like DroidDeck on a tablet with Bluetooth enabled for a mouse, then played through the TV. Can this be done? Hell, yes it can, and that wasn’t an excuse by daughter: playing on a touchscreen was amazing, as she could also use my stylus. Not that she needed it.
Like the most recent review for One More Plate, co-op games depend on who you play with. This isn’t a co-op, but it’s such an entertaining competitive experience; I can’t not recommend it. More so, watching the other person create something really amazing, then viewing a time-lapse is brill. A bit of a no-brainer, really – especially if you have some gear to play it locally, as we did.
Forgery made fun: a breathless dash through the classics with sharp competitive play. The only art crime you'll get away with.
Pros
- Brilliant local two-player with two mice
- Around 50 genuine classical artworks
- Touchscreen and stylus support works a treat
Cons
- Can be stressful by design
- Initial brushes punish detailed work
- Art is subjective :P
No Comment! Be the first one.